Articles Comments

Real Men, Real Dads » Featured, Government/Legal » Federalism Issues with Two Supreme Court Cases

Federalism Issues with Two Supreme Court Cases

This is an essay I wrote off the top of my head for a test a while back over the doctrine of standing.  These essays are not meant to be the authority on the subject, but I have edited them to the best of my knowledge to make them worthy of a read for people looking for a foundation on the topic.

Federalism Issues with Two Supreme Court Cases

In New York v. United States (1992) and Printz v. United States (1997), a very specific direction is taken regarding federalism.  The relationship between the national government and individual states has always been strained.  It gives and takes.  These two Supreme Court cases, however, placed more power in the hands of the states.

The first decision indicates that the national government may us incentives to compel states, even to the point of coercion.  The federal government may not, however, compel states through sheer penalization.  When government at the federal level can execute the action through its own constitutional powers, it may not compel states.

Furthermore, in Printz v. United States the national government is forbidden from circumvention of states by going directly to state agencies or staff.  These state actors are part of the state.  The federal government must work with the states to make the desired result occur in regards to state agencies and staff.

These two decisions increased state power and restricted the federal government.  It partially reversed a trend in federalism of bigger national government at the expense of the states.

Thank you for viewing Real Men, Real Dads. To support the site is as simple as reading posts, spreading the word, or even clicking on our advertising links on the right hand side. Please enjoy your time here on the blog!

Written by

I have experienced a wide range of emotions, events, hobbies, and jobs over my 30 years of life. My favorite is being a husband and a father, but right behind that are being a soldier, ring announcing for pro wrestling, rapping, interrogating, blogging, and background investigating. I own and operate Real Men, Real Dads ( I look forward to working with new people on exciting projects!

Filed under: Featured, Government/Legal

Leave a Reply


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>